Welcome to Johnson and Conroy Agency, Inc.

We are an Independent Agency, which means we can shop your insurance needs with more than one company. Click here for online quick quotes.

Johnson & Conroy is located in Port Jervis, New York. We offer our services to residents and businesses in:

  • Orange & Sullivan Counties in NY
  • Pike County in PA
  • Sussex County in NJ  

We offer all types of Personal Insurance coverages to our clients in New York including Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Renters Insurance, Individual Life Insurance, and Motorcycle Insurance.

Give one of our agents a call to save money on your Business Insurance. Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Business Owners Policy (BOP), Commercial Property, General Liability, Workers Compensation, and Bonds.

Let us help you cut your insurance cost in New York

Why should you do business with Johnson & Conroy:

  • We are not tied to any one company.
  • We can handle all of your insurance needs.
  • We have strong ties to our clients and community.
  • We treat you like a person, not a policy number.
  • We will shake your hand and thank you for your business.
  • We will assist you when you have a claim.

Client satisfaction is our livelihood.  Your request for an insurance quote will be forwarded to our experienced staff that will work hard to earn your trust and customize a competitive policy or package that meets your needs.

Just give us a quick call today at 845-856-5341 or Submit one of our quick online quote forms - with the help of our dedicated business partners; we conveniently offer an entire solution for all your insurance and business needs.

Ready to Request a Free Quote? GET STARTED TODAY