Johnson and Conroy Agency, Inc. Logo
Get a Quote
Call Today: 845-856-5341
Quick Quote Form
First Last
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Personal Insurance
Life Insurance

Welcome to Our Website

We provide personal service and professional insurance advice for families and businesses.  Whether you need homeowners insurance, auto insurance, renters or life insurance, Johnson & Conroy can customize a policy or a complete package to meet your specific needs.  Customized business insurance programs are also available.  We offer a wide variety of coverage for businesses including property, liability, automobile and workers compensation coverage.  Our goal is to provide all of our clients with personal service, professional advice and insurance designed to meet their specific needs.

Why should you do business with Johnson & Conroy:
  • We are not tied to any one company.
  • We can handle all of your insurance needs.
  • We have strong ties to our clients and community.
  • We treat you like a person, not a policy number.
  • We will shake your hand and thank you for your business.
  • We will assist you when you have a claim.
Client satisfaction is our livelihood.  Your request for an insurance quote will be forwarded to our experienced staff that will work hard to earn your trust and customize a competitive policy or package that meets your needs.

Johnson & Conroy is located in Port Jervis, New York and we offer our services to residents and businesses in Orange and Sullivan Counties in New York, Pike County in Pennsylvania and Sussex County in New Jersey.  We’ve been providing insurance services for over 50 years.  To speak with one of us, please call us at 845-856-5341, Monday – Friday between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.  For your convenience, you may also reach us by fax at 845-858-2446 or E-mail us at

For your Family •
For your Business •
  • Auto Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Boat & Watercraft
  • Flood Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Recreational Vehicle Insurance
  • More »
  • Business Owners Packages (BOP)
  • General Liability
  • Commercial Auto
  • Workers Compensation
  • Bonds
  • Commercial Building Property
  • Business Umbrella Policies
  • Equipment Floater
  • More »

Info Center

Find us on Facebook
The Hartford Products

Auto Insurance Quote

Get a Safeco Property Insurance Quote

Get a Safeco Property Insurance Quote

Defensive Driving Course

PO Box 3138 Port Jervis, NY 12771 | Phone: 845-856-5341 | Fax: 845-858-2446 | Email Us | Get Map
Site by: - © 2017 Johnson and Conroy Agency, Inc. - This page is valid XHTML.